|
| PLANNING DEPARTMENT TOWN OF MIDDLETOWN 350 East Main Road, Middletown, RI 02842 (401) 849-4027 | MiddletownRI.com |
PLANNING BOARD MINUTES
Regular Meeting
October 14, 2026, 6pm
Town Council Chambers – Town Hall
350 East Main Road
Middletown, RI 02842
Board members present:
Paul Croce, Chair
Joe Pierik
Matt Skirzenski
Art Weber
Steve Huttler
Charlie Vaillancourt
Members absent:
B.J. Owen
Also present:
Ron Wolanski, Town Planner
Michael Monti, Assistant Town Solicitor
Rudy Botros, Principal Planner
Chairman Croce called the meeting to order at 6:00pm.
i. Motion by Mr. Weber, seconded by Mr. Vaillancourt to receive the correspondence. Vote: 6-0-0.
i. Motion by Mr. Weber, seconded by Mr. Vaillancourt to receive the correspondence. Vote: 6-0-0.
a. Item 5.b before 4.a and items 5.a and 5.c before 4.d.
a. Public Hearing - Application of Prescott Point, LLC for combined Preliminary and Final Plan approval of a Minor Land Development Project to develop 6 additional single-family units in an existing multi-family development project. The request includes application for a special use permit under Zoning Ordinance Section 602 for expansion of a multi-family development, and request for variances from Sections 603, 903, 1506 and 1508 of the Zoning Ordinance to allow separation 25 feet between principal buildings where 50 feet is required, building height of 40 feet where 35 feet is permitted, and multi-family development to be served by private sewer system. Property located off West Main Rd. and identified as Tax Assessors Plat 104, Lot 7.
i. Heard after 5.b.
ii. Motion by Mr. Weber, seconded by Mr. Vaillancourt to open the public hearing. Vote: 6-0-0.
iii. Atty. Jeremiah Lynch on behalf of the applicant Prescott Point, LLC reviewed the original application heard two years ago. The plan had called for 20 plus individual land unit condominiums on the Middletown side of the project. The area under consideration was set aside for a nursing home facility. Since then the facility has been replaced by 6 additional units similar to the units that have been previously approved. The current application seeks the same dimensional variances that were sought previously in 2024. The change will result in a decrease in impervious surface.
iv. In response to a question posed by Mr. Weber, Atty. Lynch stated that the change was made because no one wanted to operate a nursing home facility.
v. P.E. Lynn Small of Northeast Engineering, explained that the Portsmouth houses were mostly built and that they are now putting in the roadway to access the sites of the Middletown units. The change has resulted in a decrease in impervious area and a reduction in wastewater. The road network is in place, infrastructure has already been approved, and state wetland and RIPDES permit have been secured. The change still meets all requirements.
vi. Mr. Pierik, asked what the stormwater impact would be with the change and asked Ms. Small to review the building height.
vii. In response to a question posed by Mr. Pierik, Ms. Small explained that most of the project is in Portsmouth where a 40 feet height is allowed but the houses will remain at 35 feet. The site is a brownfield and fill had to be brought in to cap it. She explained that Rhode Island has a very low threshold for arsenic but if this project had been built in Massachusetts they would not have to cap it. Since the height is measured at current grade rather than the proposed grade, a height variance had to be requested but at the end of construction the height will meet the 35 ft requirement. The proposed houses will allow stormwater to flow towards the collection systems located in the roadways and conveyed down to the stormwater treatment systems that discharge to the wetlands in the southwest corner.
viii. In response to a question posed by Mr. Skirzenski, Atty. Lynch explained the sidewalk has not yet been built because the units have not been built. The houses will have a shared driveway and not need their own sidewalks.
ix. Mr. Skirzenski stated that the extra units will increase queue time on the left hand turn lane onto West Main Rd., which is not signalized from 109 seconds to 170 seconds and increase the distance from 25 to 35 feet. He explained that there have already been 6 accidents in three years on that left hand turn and that although it is signed at 35 mph it has a median speed of 45 mph. He asked if the state was asked about signalizing or creating a rotary at that intersection.
x. Mr. Christopher Bicho responded that the state was consulted and a traffic study conducted but even with the additional 6 units the development does not qualify for a signalized intersection. The traffic study is funded by the applicant while the actual signalization is funded by the state.
xi. Mr. Weber noted that further development on the other side of West Main Road may force the state to take action.
xii. Mr. Bicho stated that Portsmouth is also holding $100k for possible signalization. The associated study has been completed but it’s possible those funds will be used for a further study.
xiii. In response to questioning by Mr. Huttler, Mr. Bicho explained that there is no public sewer on West Main Rd., in that area, and in 2005 a private sewer system was granted.
xiv. In response to questioning by Mr.Huttler, Mr. Bicho explained that the 25 feet separation between houses where 50 feet is required has been requested to remain consistent with the character of the development as a whole and this allows for more housing. The fire relief is 10 feet. If that variance were not granted they would have to decrease the number of houses on that parcel.
xv. Chairman Croce asked if any members of the public wished to speak.
xvi. Motion by Mr. Weber, seconded by Mr. Vaillancourt to close the public hearing. Vote: 6-0-0.
xvii. Motion by Mr. Weber, seconded by Mr. Vaillancourt to approve the Special Use Permit and the two variances including the findings. Vote: 6-0-0.
xviii. Motion by Mr. Weber, seconded by Mr. Vaillancourt to approve the preliminary and final plan request for the land development project subject to the findings. Vote: 6-0-0.
b. Receive court decision, order and judgment, and memorandum from solicitor regarding appeal of Planning Board approval of a land development project application of Seascape Holdings, LLC involving property at 985 Aquidneck ave., Assessor’s Plat 113, Lot 208, Planning Board decision dated April 2, 2025, and discuss the same.
i. Mr. Vaillancourt recused himself from the deliberations.
ii. Mr. Huttler asked for clarification from Atty. Monti regarding how to proceed since he was not a Boardmember at the time this case was deliberated.
iii. Mr. Monti explained that the Superior Court is looking for a technical remedy with an amended decision that explicitly states why Board members voted the way they did, consistent with regulations. The Superior Court justice is asking for the Board members to connect the dots better in the decision so that he can review it adequately.
iv. It was agreed that after everyone has reviewed the record and an amended decision is written the Board members will deliberate their acceptance of it. If more time is needed the process can be iterative and discussed further.
v. Mr. Croce stated he would relinquish the chairmanship back to Mr. Weber consistent with Board’s makeup originally, to allow Mr. Croce to state his previous negative vote on the application.
i. Mr. Francis Spinella, the Middletown housing consultant, explained that the ordinance should be consistent with state recommended maximums set at 80% of AMI for rental and 120% of AMI for home ownership. However, the Board could chose to lower these figures as recommended by the Affordable Housing Committee.
ii. Mr. Spinella explained that the Affordable Housing Committee had initiated a study that showed that housing at every income level needed to be developed. Through income averaging a housing unit can have some units rented to those who are at 30% AMI and some at 80% AMI. As long as the average income is 60% AMI the development still counts for a low-income housing tax credit (LIHTC).
iii. Mr. Skirzenski asked what would happen if both figures were lowered. Mr. Spinella answered that some people would still qualify because their income will stall fall within guidelines and they may have money available for a larger down payment if for instance they had sold their previous house.
iv. Mr. Vaillancourt asked if it was possible to make the affordable housing requirement voluntary for owners developing withing the ordinary permitted density and mandatory for those choosing the density bonus. He asked if the mandatory requirement is retained what evidence shows that the compensation is enough.
v. Mr. Spinella answered that anyone can deed restrict their home and make it count towards the town’s affordable housing inventory. In this case they would have to sell it to someone else in their income brackets and would not appreciate the increase in housing equity that has occurred. The 10 unit mandate is good and as developer still has the option of using the comprehensive permit application.
vi. In response to Mr. Vaillancourt’s question as to why it has to be mandatory, Mr. Spinella explained that if the community is serious about creating affordable housing we have to increase density and keep it mandatory otherwise there is no use in passing anything. The only way to do this is through inclusionary zoning.
vii. Mr. Spinella also stated that the 15% unit increase is net neutral because it does not increase the affordable housing percentage in the community because there would also be an increase in market housing within the same development. He would recommend 20% at a minimum or 25% which according to the state is what is necessary to actually increase affordability while building both affordable and market rate housing.
viii. Mr. Huttler reiterated Mr. Vaillancourt’s suggestion that if the ordinance is mandatory it might discourage a developer from building anything at all while the community still needs housing production at all income levels. As it’s currently written if a developer wants to build 10 units he must build with affordable units or not build at all.
ix. Mr. Spinella argued that if it’s optional no one will use it and they would rather build market rate housing to maximize profits, the biggest houses on the smallest lot. If it’s optional do not even bother submitting any ordinance. An affordable housing developer will always use the comprehensive permit process rather than this.
x. In response to questioning by Mr. Skirzenski, Mr. Spinella explained that 25% is consistent with RIGL 45.53, the comprehensive permit legislation that sets the 80% and 120% AMI figures but maybe a good compromise would be 20%. This would capture those who do not want to take the comprehensive permit route but still build at least 10 units.
xi. Mr. Spinella noted that the ordinance should include language that says if a lot can accommodate 10 units or more that it be addressed up front so that developers do not skirt the requirement. Mr. Wolanski stated that the ordinance has a 15 year look back period to avoid this.
xii. Mr. Weber stated the actual rental cost of the units is increasing as well and that may require a lower maximum than 80%. Mr. Spinella explained that AMI changes annually based on HUD data.
xiii. Mr. Pierik stated that he has an issue with the mandatory nature of the ordinance and that the incentive should be enticing enough that developers would want to use it. Mr. Spinella explained that the density bonus of the market rate home is a good incentive. If the developer is allowed 10 units but also builds two affordable units he can then build an additional 2 market rate units.
xiv. Mr. Huttler stated that the proposal is not giving a bonus market rate unit for each affordable unit. For example:
Where 20 lots/units are permitted/proposed: 20 x 0.1725 = 3.45, or 4 affordable units, resulting in 4 additional market rate units. This results in 24 total units with 4 affordable or 16.6% affordable.
Mr. Huttler stated there was no real incentive here and that he would be opposed to making this proposal mandatory otherwise.
xv. Mr. Wolanski explained that the original intent was not to provide an incentive but rather just make it mandatory to build affordable housing.
xvi. Mr. Vaillancourt echoed Mr. Huttler’s concern.
xvii. Atty. Monti stated that in most towns that have a mandatory inclusionary zoning ordinance most developers end up using the comprehensive permit legislation, because the incentive is there and the permitting process is easier.
xviii. Mr. Croce recommended and it was agreed that he would work out a better incentive with Mr. Wolanski and revisit this proposal keeping the proposal mandatory.
xix. In response to a question posed by Mr. Huttler, Mr. Spinella explained that building affordable is not necessarily more expensive the issue is primarily the cost of land and if that number can be diminished the developer can break even or make a profit even on affordable homes. This is why the density bonus is so valuable.
xx. In response to a follow-up question posed by Mr. Skirzenski, Mr. Spinella explained that many factors are at play that determine whether or not a developer will want to build. Different communities have different land costs and also different infrastructure in place. Affordable housing employs many different types of subsidies to allow housing development to be financially feasible.
xxi. Mr. Huttler asked that a review include a comparison to the comprehensive permit process. Mr. Wolanski explained that once the town reaches 10% affordable which could happen over the next few years, the comprehensive permit option would no longer be in play.
xxii. Mr. Spinella explained that it’s important to increase the 15% figure because as it stands the town would be going backwards in its effort to achieve 10% affordable.
a. Request of Morrison Farm, LLC for release of subdivision performance security for the Morrison Farm Subdivision in accordance with Section 703 of the Middletown Rules and Regulation Regarding the Subdivision and Development of Land.
i. Atty. David Martland on behalf of the applicant, reviewed the proposal to release the security performance guarantee associated with the development. This would allow a recommendation to the Town Council for final approval. DPW and the Town Engineer have certified completion of the public improvements. Release of the surety is also contingent on the posting of a maintenance bond of at least 10%, which is $29,501.25 held for a year following acceptance by the Town Council.
ii. In response to a question posed by Mr. Croce, Mr. Wolanski explained that the PB is voting to release the security and there is no requirement of the Town Council to accept a recommendation. The security in this case was a lien on one lot and the release would allow that lot to be sold and developed. A maintenance security in the form of a bond or cash would be held for a year and then after certification from the Town Engineer it would be released.
iii. Mr. Vaillancourt expressed his satisfaction with DPW’s and the Town Engineer’s recommendation for release.
iv. Motion by Mr. Huttler, seconded by Mr. Vaillancourt to release the performance security on the Morrison Farm subdivision. Vote: 6-0-0.
b. Review of projects proposed for inclusion in the Town’s PY25 Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) application and determination of consistency with the Middletown Comprehensive Community Plan.
i. Heard before 4.a.
ii. Mr. Huttler stated he appreciated Mr. Wolanski’s review and agreed that it was consistent with the comprehensive plan.
iii. Motion by Mr. Weber, seconded by Mr. Vaillancourt to declare that the projects are consistent with the Comprehensive Community Plan. Vote: 6-0-0.
c. Request of Narragansett Engineering, Inc., on behalf of The Tide Club, 116-124 Aquidneck Ave., for concept review of a potential redevelopment project for the subject property. Property Identified as lots 135, 136, 137 on Assessor’s Plat 115SE.
i. Atty. Tanner Jackson of Miller, Scott, Holbrook and Jackson on behalf of the property owner, TC Capital LLC, discussed the pre-application concept review. The applicant proposes a redevelopment of three lots located on 116 to 124 Aquidneck Avenue. He introduced the team working on the project.
ii. Mr. Mason, the property owner described the project as a health club that will offer a variety of public amenities and stay consistent with regulations of the Atlantic Beach Overlay District.
iii. Kite Architecture described the elevations, floor plans and what the building will look like. The representative stated that the building will meet the design guidelines associated with the Atlantic Beach Overlay District.
1. Mr. Weber expressed his appreciation for the New England coastal design that is being incorporated into the building.
2. Mr. Pierik inquired about the proposed and existing curb cuts and the topography of the lot.
3. Mr. Vaillancourt asked about the lot coverage.
a. The Naragansett Engineer representative answered that the proposed lot coverage is 28.75% which would require a dimensional variance.
4. Mr. Croce confirmed that two buildings currently on the site encroach on the sidewalks and that they would be demolished to allow for a new construction that will meet all the setbacks.
5. Mr. Huttler reviewed the emphasis the Board puts on stormwater runoff mitigation and that mitigation should look aesthetically pleasing.
a. The Naragansett Engineer representative explained that the site will be compliant in this regard. He went on to describe all aspects of the proposal in a thorough presentation.
6. Mr. Skirzenski confirmed that the proposed building will be elevated above the 100-year flood plain.
7. Mr. Pierik confirmed that construction is not likely to trigger any DEM oversight because it was not contaminated.
8. Mr. Weber confirmed that Coastal Resources Management will have some oversight regarding the stormwater runoff review rather than DEM.
9. Mr. Skirzenski appreciated the reduction of curb cuts from 3 to 1.
10. Mr. Croce reviewed the traffic report requirements with the Northeast Engineer’s representative.
d. Request of the Town Council for a recommendation on a proposed amendment to Town Code Chapter 152, Zoning Code, Section 728 regarding short-term rentals in adaptive reuse projects.
i. Mr. Vaillancourt stated his disagreement with disallowing residents from using a hosting platform when the intent is to prevent renting property for less than 31 days.
ii. Mr. Weber stated that he was opposed to short-term rentals because they decrease the number of housing units available.
iii. Mr. Croce stated that the intent behind adaptive reuse is to encourage housing production, and so he supported the change to prohibit short-term rentals.
iv. This sentiment was echoed by all the Board members.
v. Motion by Mr. Skirzenski, seconded by Mr. Vaillancourt to recommend to the Town Council the adoption of the proposed change. Vote: 6-0-0.
i. Mr. Croce asked that the Solicitor’s move forward on the use table review.
i. Tree Commission
1. Ms. Owen was not in attendance.
ii. Open Space and Fields Committee
1. Mr. Vaillancourt is waiting to hear from the new Chair regarding updates.
iii. Conservation Commission
1. Mr. Skirzenski stated the committee did not meet in September but they hoped to meet in October.
iv. Mr. Croce noted that the memo from the Town Administrator omitted the Tree Commission from its list of Boards and Commissions and asked that it would be added.
i. Legislative Changes and Proposed Comprehensive Plan Review – October 22, 2016, 6pm.
ii. Regular Planning Board meeting – November 12, 2026, 6pm.
iii. Soon to be scheduled meeting regarding a Stormwater Utility and a Wastewater Management District.
Motion by Mr. Skirzenski, seconded by Mr. Vaillancourt to adjourn the meeting. Vote: 6-0-0
Meeting adjourned at approximately 8:00 pm.
Respectfully submitted,
Arthur S. Weber, Jr., Secretary